Brandon E. Young Design
  • Blog
  • Profile
  • Portfolio
  • Graphic Design
  • Contact

Publications: Part Four

10/10/2011

0 Comments

 
The City Image and its Elements

Picture
I admire the clarity and organization of this book by Kevin Lynch. The path, which Lynch recognizes as “channels along which the observer customarily, occasionally, or potentially moves,” can be misleading from the image of the city. Particularly, the freeway, which divides and cuts through the city, separating the elements into districts and zones. The freeway makes the subject oblivious to their surrounding; camouflaging the image of the city in place of road signs and traffic. Take for example, the shoreway in Cleveland, which runs from Lakewood through downtown Cleveland. The shoreway portrays this role as a divider. The numerous exits and turns distract the driver from recognizing the city around them. Coming off an exit ramp is “typically a moment of severe disorientation.” As Lynch notes, even familiar drivers show a surprising’ lack of knowledge of the freeway system and its connections in the case with Los Angeles. Another good example is Pittsburgh. I find myself paying close attention to the complex transportation routes and interchanges rather than taking in the image of the city.

My first comment leads to another observation I’ve made in the case of the image of the city. I have noticed, through my experience so far in Cleveland, that the junction, or the place of a break in transportation, has a compelling significance for the city observer. Lynch notes these areas as being nodes into which the observer can enter. As Lynch quotes, “because decisions must be made at junctions, people heighten their attention at such places and perceive nearby elements with more than normal clarity.” I can agree with this statement up to a certain point. I believe that people heighten their attention at these places, but I don’t necessarily believe that they pay closer attention to the nearby elements of the city. A good example is Euclid corridor. As I was observing people walking across Euclid Corridor I noticed that most of their attention was directed toward the traffic and the traffic signals rather than what I would consider the “elements” of the city: the architecture, the buildings, the landscape, the streetscape, and the people. Euclid corridor seems to serve its purpose: it interrupts the thoughts in your brain if only for a moment and portrays that junction point that Lynch notes as a structural unit dividing the city. 

Camillo Sitte and “The Art of Building Cities”

Picture
Sitte notes the importance of the public square in ancient times and how modern planners and designers lack the ability to maintain that same degree of importance with cities today. Cities no longer have distinct character. Merging ideas and motifs from various cities creates cities that are mingled in character. It would be interesting to compare Colin Rowe and “Collage Cities” with Camillo Sitte. According to Sitte, as a result of “Collage Cities,” local characteristics are gradually disappearing. In comparison, Rowe proposes a city which can accommodate a whole range of utopias in miniature.

The Soaring Twenties

Picture
This excerpt recognizes a theme, whether or not the author intended to or not, that I have studied most recently and that is the theme of “individualism vs. collectivism,” not in politics but within a man’s soul. This theme is most portrayed in the field of architecture because, as Bascomb mentions, “man wanted to make his mark on the world, and the structures he built became a statement of self.” During the time that this book was written, America was going through a dramatic change in Architecture, among many other things. The switch from a classical style of architecture to a more modern style received much criticism. A classical representation was considered a collective motif; one that reflected the conservative values of society. The modern style portrayed individuality in the sense that it only conformed to the needs of a select few architects. Individualism can be attributed to tall buildings, like Bascomb makes clear in his book. “The Woolworth Building was going to be like a giant signboard to advertise around the world [my] spreading chain of five-and-ten cent-stores.” But lets face it, we find satisfaction in the idea that our buildings are a reflection of ourselves and so why should we be anything but autonomous thinkers; not molded playthings of “social conditioning.”

New York, New York: How the Apartment House Transformed the Life of the City

Picture
As little as I know about New York City, this reading helped me recognize the impact it had on the rest of the America. Although the apartment house was an old European way of life, many Americans saw it as a vision of the future, and there lies the difference. The apartment house helped reconnect the city that was once a series of separate households, as most suburban areas are today. A new community of interests was established, promising a new sociality. Planners began designing residential blocks rather than individual buildings; complexes rather than units. It was this type of change that made people evolve from European to an American way: we are innovators to our own success, we learn from our own mistakes and other countries will learn from us.

0 Comments

    AUTHOR

    Brandon E. Young
    Cleveland-Based Architect and Designer

    Picture

    ARCHIVES

    September 2020
    August 2020
    May 2020
    October 2018
    May 2018
    October 2016
    September 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    October 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011

    CATEGORIES

    All
    Allan Jacobs
    Americas Cup
    Aqua Tower
    Arthur Wright
    Artspace
    Auckland
    Ayn Rand
    Brasilia Plan
    Broadacre City
    Camillo Sitte
    Chicago
    City Life
    City Of Bits
    Cleveland
    Cleveland Casino
    Cleveland Design Competition
    Collar Ties
    Combinatory Urbanism
    Concrete And Clay
    Concrete Vs Asphalt
    Conflict
    Constructed Wetlands
    Creative Class
    CUDC Welcoming + Orientation Guide
    Cuyahoga River
    Deconstruction
    Detroit Shoreway
    Detroit Superior Bridge
    Detroit-superior Bridge
    Doan Brook Watershed
    Dpz Architects
    Dugway Creek Watershed
    Earth Works
    Ecology
    Economic Growth
    Economy
    Elizabeth Hawkes
    Euclid Corridor
    Flats East Bank
    Fountainhead
    Frank Lloyd Wright
    High Speed Rail
    Home Renovation
    Ibm Building
    Jane Jacobs
    Joseph Rykwert
    Kevin Lynch
    La
    Lafayette Park
    Lakewood
    Land Cover
    Land Use
    Lane Barden
    Las Vegas
    Las Vegas After Its Classical Age
    Le Corbusier
    Led
    Lineposters
    London
    Market Ecology
    Medical Mart And Convention Center
    Mies Van Der Rohe
    Monument
    Narrative
    Nature Center At Shaker Lakes
    Neal Bascomb
    New Orleans
    Nine Mile Creek
    Oak Park
    Ohio Epa
    Olympic Park
    Open Spaces
    Origami Tessellations
    Publications
    Qulaity Of Place
    Radiant City
    Residential
    Richard Florida
    Richard Sennett
    Rustbelt
    Rustbelt Chic
    Shrinking Cities
    Site Visit
    Soho Effect
    Stormwater Impact
    Stormwater Management
    Streetsboro
    Studio
    Studio Gang
    Sub Urban
    Succession
    Sustainability
    Swales
    Symbolic Culture
    Symbolic Infrastructure
    Symbolic Monument
    The City Of Towers
    The Conscience Of The Eye
    The Death And Life Of Great American Cities
    The Detroit Shoreway
    The Economy Of Cities
    The Fountainhead
    The Idea Of A Town
    The Image Of The City
    The Junction
    The Life Of An Architecture Student
    The Neutral City
    The New Las Vegas
    The Parallels
    The Rise Of The Creative Class
    The Three T's Of Economic Growth
    Third Floor Renovation
    Tiny House
    Transect Design
    Treatment Approach
    Uli Competition
    Urban Bean Coffee House
    Urban Design
    Urban Systems
    Vacancy
    Water
    West Creek Watershed
    Wetland Park
    William Mitchell
    Witold Rybczynski

  • Blog
  • Profile
  • Portfolio
  • Graphic Design
  • Contact